(agg.) = Aggregate score | (a) = Won on away goals
2008 – 2010: there was no final. The title was decided by a round robin between the clubs, and the runner-up is the club that finished second.
(b) The 2nd leg of the 2011 final was abandoned in the 60th minute due to bad weather with the Whitecaps leading 1-0 (2-1 on aggregate). It was replayed over a month later from 0-0, and Toronto FC won 2-1 (3-2 on aggregate).